00:00
Welcome back to the Raw Selection Private Equity Podcast. Joining us today is Andrew Weinberg, founder and chief exec of Brightstar Capital Partners, a U.S. private equity firm investing in the middle market. Andrew, if you could give us a brief insight into you, Sure. Thanks so much, Alex. So in terms of gets insight into me, think self-awareness is always a challenge. But I would say the following, which is
00:28
I've always been a big believer in cultures, what we call it Bright Star, a PhD culture and poor, hungry and driven. And I didn't coin the phrase, but from an outlook perspective, understanding the role that we occupy and then to me, always understanding that the us and us is something that I've always really tried to drive throughout my career. If I think back, I'm a big believer in the apprentice model. So I've benefited from so many mentors over time, some of whom are still very involved in my life.
00:57
And so I've also, in addition to believing in apprentice culture, actually been some of the sort of fairly risk averse, ironically in a risk taking business. I think we do measured risk, but I've always sort of chosen the path that gave me the broadest skillset, the best insight exposure to some of the smartest people out there to be successful on this journey for a long period of time. In terms of me personally, I did meet my wife when I was 17. I convinced her to date me when we were 27.
01:27
So in terms of like a long sales cycle, I'm actually pretty familiar with what it takes to have determination and motivation and patience. I like that a lot. So PhD, we'll dive into PhD culture first actually, because that's a new one on me. When we talk about culture, think a lot of people talk about kind of what I regard as fluff. And we get this in executive search where they kind of say, we're hardworking, we're motivated. It doesn't really mean anything.
01:54
What are the examples of actions in your firm that demonstrate the culture that you coin PhD? Yeah, I would say a few things, which is everyone's got a voice at the table. So I really don't love hierarchical cultures. I like cultures where everyone feels like their voice is heard, understood. I also appreciate when someone's actually done the work to have a great informed view. And I love these three words. I don't know.
02:24
from any level, any person, any title, when someone says, don't know, to me, that's actually confidence. That humility is actually something that becomes pervasive in a culture. And I'm also a big believer in team. So I love having a team-based culture. And if you get to know some of the folks at Bright Star, think you'll see that. I'd also say we're pretty hard charging. We work in a very competitive industry. And so our investors have so many choices of where to put their capital.
02:54
And they have to trust us that we're going to be great stewards of that capital and outperform the market. So I think with that drive, I've been influenced like my partner and co-chair Marcelo Clare is someone that I backed nearly 20 years ago. He's been an amazing influence in my life. He's been one of the most successful CEOs in the world. And having him with us full time has been a game changer for Brightstar, especially as we lean into this new world of applying AI. But culturally again,
03:23
If you think about what Marcelo has done at various stages of his career, that is something that I aspire to. Excellent. What's one mistake that you see private equity or portfolio companies making and what would you suggest to correct them? Yeah, Alex, how long do we have again for this session? I think there are some stark mistakes and I think it's always inflection points that point out those mistakes. And I say inflection points.
03:50
In 22 and 23, we saw a very different environment, geopolitical interest rate, the exit environment really changed. So I'm going to focus actually on the exit. We went through a 15 to 20 year period. I think McKinsey recently chronicled this by saying 60 % of the uplift in value came from multiple expansion and leverage in the pre-22 era. If we roll forward from where we've gone since then,
04:19
we see a tremendous backlog of companies that haven't been sold. So mistakes made are not spending a lot of time upfront on how we're gonna exit these investments, how to create those pathways, how to get to know the potential buyers ahead of running a process. So the company is very familiar to that base. And optimally, there is very strong strategic interest in that company, which tends to drive again,
04:47
a very active and robust exit process. And we've actually seen that on multiple occasions since 2022.
04:55
So it's no news to anybody in private equity that exits have slowed and it's been a bit of a challenging period, probably for the last two or three, well, definitely three, I would say, years. But what's your take on the state of play of the middle market? Yeah. So I'd say a couple of things. If I take a big macro step back and I'll really hone in more in the United States, all this is applicable to global.
05:21
The middle market itself has been a robust engine. It tends to be the part of the economy that grows when other parts aren't. It's sort of the backbone of most countries. And in the US, actually proved to be more resilient in the GFC. The middle market is growing. And in fact, we're going to see a intergenerational wealth transfer of more than $100 trillion in the US in the next 25 years. And when you pair that up with, from our research that we've done with a group,
05:51
you know, 60 % of these businesses don't have a succession plan in the middle market. Communications are a challenge. It's not always clear actually if the next generation wants to be involved in the business on a day to day, maybe not even an ownership perspective. So the middle market to me is exciting because it's very investable. And frankly, it is generally the market that is not buying a public security, right? This is not a click a button, buy and click a button sell. These are building relationships.
06:20
And really being able to articulate why we are more than capital. So I love the resiliency. I love the fact that it's the backbone and I love the fact when you can sprinkle both capital and know-how of value creation. I think we can take good and very good businesses and make them very good and great. So you mentioned AI. How is AI being leveraged by the middle market?
06:46
Again, I'll quote another study. think there was a survey recently that said six to 7 % of private equity firms were kind of using AI today or really applying it in any meaningful way. And yet 70 % believe it's going to be critical for the next five years. We do it really in two ways. First, ourselves, how can we ask our portfolio companies or talk to potential companies to invest in about applying AI if we're not doing it ourselves?
07:15
So we have a very dedicated team, a number of people internally at Bright Star. We just finished one of our most recent all day sessions where we go offline from eight to six to work together in a team-based environment across the entire firm. Everyone from our receptionist to partner working on building agents. We now have almost a hundred agents actively working day to day at Bright Star alongside just under a hundred Bright Stars.
07:44
My guess is Alex, in a few months, there'll be a couple hundred agents and all of us are now equipped to build them. So I can't think of a technology that's been more democratized than AI absent the cost of tokens. Okay. So that is a real cost, but in terms of the ability to use and to really displace traditional systems, software that was put in place that didn't want us to really get involved. Now, what we're doing is we're discussing problems.
08:12
and building solutions as a team. So AI for us internally is a great unlock. I can think of negotiations, preparation for meetings. We're literally taking hours, days, and weeks and shrinking it to minutes and hours in terms of the ability. And from a risk management perspective internally, we've built a number of tools from our Red Team memo, how to make better decisions as an investment committee. It's actually been amazing.
08:41
I have to remind my family, you know, AI is inanimate, but it is one of the, you know, the, the, I talked to AI quite frequently and AI has really good feedback. Um, and it's really become a good thought partner. think if I now think about the portfolio companies, we have a very deliberate effort of applying AI and we built a very strong team internally to apply AI to our portfolio companies. And the, these use cases are going to.
09:10
really span sales and marketing, customer service, being able to really kind of remove some software, supply chain, procurement, back office. There are a number of different use cases. And the great thing for us is given our scale, once we apply that solution to one company, we can port that over to the other company. And that knowledge transfer is really critical. And I think that actually becomes one of the reasons.
09:39
why companies will choose to partner with us, i.e. allow us to invest in them. Okay, interesting. Artificial intelligence always a hot topic. Yeah, so those agents have a variety of tasks and we get to define them and redefine them. But if you think about what we do every day, we try to go find great companies to invest in. So from a sourcing perspective, really helping us hone in on the sectors where we have theses in terms of where to invest.
10:08
Think of areas of business services, areas of industrials, areas of education that we think are right. And then sub kind of verticals or sub theses there, allowing us to really map the value creation, map the opportunity set, map the advisors or operating partners we'd want around this opportunity to build value. And really almost think of testing our thesis before making the investment. Now, of course, reality happens is, and we don't have a crystal ball of the future.
10:36
but we can really scenario play a lot better today than we could before. As we break from sourcing into diligence and execution, think of really shrinking the turn times on diligence, on materials that come and the ability to ask good questions. The ability to ask good questions of management from a more informed perspective than maybe having to wait a few days to reflect on it.
10:59
When we get to the value creation phase, we're really, we've already built a value creation plan before we've invested. That's always been core to the bright star thesis. But now again, we get to test it against how we've done before. And then when we get to the exit, it allows us to constantly monitor that exit environment. What strategic were we counting on to show up in our auction? What sponsors did we think really were interested in the space and really tracking that? And then we also get to go back and do post mortems.
11:29
So we frequently as an investment committee, as we're thinking about new investments, we have our red team memo, it plays the devil's advocate. If we say something's great, it will find every reason it's not great, right? Every time, the more sensational the claim, the more sensational the feedback is, why not? And that really provides, now we don't outsource our thinking to that tool, but we do wanna use that tool to make better decisions. And I'd say this, don't play errorless ball.
11:57
So we want to go back and do postmortems on our companies. If something went well, okay, let's understand how to move up. If something didn't go well, let's figure out the root cause analysis. And those are just very, very basic things. I mean, we have a number of other areas at the firm where those agents are active on a frequent basis. And I think what's allowing us to do is really spend more time thinking and less time doing the mechanical of doing. We still have an incredibly strong team. They're probably covering a little more ground.
12:26
than they used to before these AI tools. And I love it because what we're seeing is it's actually covering every age spectrum across our firm. I love the fact that our newer team members who maybe have a little less experience can come in, but armed with AI can really get up the learning curve a lot quicker than they did before AI.
12:48
Sorry to interrupt, just a quick mention of our longstanding partnership with Grata. As you all probably know, the private equity scene is constantly evolving and deal flow is moving now to proprietary and data-driven processes. Grata provides you with the data and information of over 7 million private companies. So if you're looking to improve your proprietary deal flow and improve the data access, then reach out to Grata today. Now back to the podcast.
13:18
And what's, so for the portfolio side, what's one or two use cases that you've used for AI that has been applied to all or most of your portfolio companies? Yes. So I won't go in the all or most yet, just because we're still in that journey of really rolling it out. We own an education business over in the UK called Ordin, and they have a number of tools that they've been putting in place to do a couple things.
13:45
How do you make the onboarding process easier for the student and more seamless and sort of shrink that time? So the time that I'm really interested, how do I get onboard faster? And then what we're also developing, and we have some partnerships that we'll announce in the future, how do we actually increase the probability of that student finishing his or her degree? This is a prevalent theme across all education, which is,
14:13
How do I stay in that education journey, which generally leads to an uplift in income, a better outcome for both the person and for society. And that would just be a couple of specific use cases. We own an auto auction business in the US. We have 60 locations. We transact in about 1 million vehicles roughly a year. And one of the things we think about is we want to make sure that we have happy customers. And when you run an auto auction business, not everyone's going to prevail in that auction.
14:43
So maybe we're second or third place for that F-150 that you wanted or a Toyota pickup or something like that. Well, if we can use AI to seamlessly identify, do we have that vehicle in our system? Can we deliver it to you cost effectively? And again, maybe it's 90 miles away at another one of our locations. AI can do that with a speed that the human never could.
15:12
With that, you mentioned about the great wealth transfer. What is your take on what happens with the businesses within the middle market? Yeah. So I think what the great wealth transfer is doing is really giving optionality. Okay. So if we go back in time, again, I'm a student of history. Um, and we think back maybe a hundred years ago, it used to be that in a lot of societies, including the U S a business would be transitioned to the eldest male.
15:42
Thankfully that was democratized and gender equality kicked in. And so you saw ownership actually distributed among multiple children. Then those children had children. And so the purity and simplicity of the single owner, single governance model now went to the law of numbers and exponentially, more, the bigger the family became, three kids each, three generations later, you have 27 stakeholders. Coming back to it,
16:12
For a public company, it's fairly easy. If I don't wanna be an owner, I sell my shares. If I wanna be a bigger owner, I buy more shares. In a private company, it's not so simple and that's really the market that we focus on. Private companies find that they operate in dynamic environments. They operate in environments that require capital on occasion, that have consolidation opportunities or maybe consolidated and don't naturally have a partner and most families don't really wanna rely upon maximizing leverage.
16:42
and putting that type of risk on a business, nor do we, for example. But when we can combine equity and debt and know-how, I think in this wealth transfer, what you're going to see is those families, founders and entrepreneurs that really wanna lean into their business are gonna have solutions to really buy out non-active members of the ownership and really create better alignment. I think in the middle market, what we've done is, we own
17:09
roughly one out of every eight or 10 Bobcat dealers in the country. And we expanded the ownership group from three owners. We bought three businesses and combined them to about 50 owners. So the ability to really grow the ownership and that ownership mentality has really also been core to our thesis. And I think what comes out is more options, much like the maturation of private equity and the ability for investors to find what part of private equity they want to invest in.
17:38
I think these middle market businesses are able to find multiple solutions. So if you came to a bright star, you'd come and say, you know, I'd like to have a majority partner in my business who wakes up every day and cares so much about the business, wants to be a great partner, won't be here forever, but for this stage of the journey will allow not only an opportunity to distribute capital day one, but really grow the rollover capital over that period of time. Other family businesses are
18:06
Closely held businesses might want a minority owner. They might want structured capital. And the beauty today is those families really have those businesses, a menu of options. So obviously a lot of the companies you're going to speak to are going to be in that middle market, potentially if it's obviously first time private equity or founder owned currently, the appetite. Do you think obviously with population size being a bit of a funnel at this point and that mid-market being
18:35
obviously holding a lot of the wealth and also the businesses. Is there much appetite from the generation below them to continue the legacy or do you think there's going to be a large influx of businesses with no real succession plan? Yeah. So I think again, if we think about that distribution of what is the next generation thinking, I think the next generation and the prior generation with them needs to decide.
19:03
What role that generation wants to play? Do they want to be purely an owner? Do they want to be an owner and an operator? And I think once the family members or a part of the owner makes their decisions, we see a number of great businesses where the families opted to have non-family members leading the business on a day to day. We've also seen the opposite, which is the family is deeply entrenched in the senior management team. think the great part is again, the optionality that they have.
19:32
And there's always a value to an option. So the ability for that ownership group to say, you'd like to be ownership and leadership, you take one role. You want to be purely ownership, you take a different role, probably on the board. And you, if you really don't want to be involved, we'll find a way for a firm to come in and help acquire your stake and give you liquidity to go do something else and grow that capital in the way you want to grow it.
20:02
So again, for us, I don't think our business would exist a hundred years ago or not in this way and not in this robust way. But law of gravity takes over, is something always changes. Think again of late 2022 and the early AI models. Like think of where we are now and how much the world has changed. Think about where these businesses are in their journey, which is maybe going along very smoothly, everything's going great. All of a sudden.
20:31
AI happens, is this a headwind or a tailwind? Do I have a thought partner to live this journey with? Do I have someone that has the experience of managing through this, both from a existential threat and then an opportunity? So for us and our business, actually more change is generally better.
20:51
Absolutely. What's, um, what has been your biggest takeaways? You've worked with some obviously large AUM firm, Lindsay Goldberg. also been at Goldman and Morgan Stanley. What have been your biggest learning points and takeaways that's allowed you to continue your success with Bright Star? Yeah. I've really had the great fortune prior to founding Bright Star more than a decade ago, um, of working at some amazing institutions. If I think about...
21:19
Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, Lindsay Goldberg, all had built great firms, great brands, great training actually would be the hallmark. And there was a lot of crossover when I was at Lindsay Goldberg, a number of the founders had come from Morgan Stanley. And if I think about it, it was not only the training, but the network that was created out of those experiences. And it's not always obvious in the moment how valuable those networks can be, but over time, the ability to...
21:48
call on someone, ask for advice, get thoughts and feedback. That's been an amazing, amazing part of the journey. I aspire for Bright Star. I think we're roughly a similar size, maybe a little bit smaller, but not far to Lindsay Goldberg when I left there a number of years ago. And I'd love for us to be considered in that same sort of pantheon of firms. I still have a lot of friends at all of those firms.
22:16
And again, I think about this life journey as you never know where life will take you, but it's great to proactively choose an environment that I think will be suitable. Now, what do I not miss? You know, I think you're where you're calling from today. You know, I used to have to take the Docklands light rail to my office at Canary Wharf in London when I was in Morgan Stanley as an analyst. And if you miss the train, you miss the train. So there's some elements I don't miss.
22:45
I would say that my takeaway is also a lot of those firms are really great office cultures. At Bright Star, we're five days a week in the office. We do travel quite a bit, but we really love that team-based culture. And if I think about all those organizations, I think about team. I think one thing I don't hear a lot about from the podcast from investors is anything around training of their people in the private equity firm. There's a lot of focus on the...
23:14
There's horrible people that work at the portfolio companies who don't do their job well enough and need training and support. I obviously say that in jest, but we don't talk and I don't think anyone's mentioned on the podcast 200 plus episodes in and no one's talked about training and development of their people in the firm. I'm not saying they don't do it, just saying don't talk about it. What have you taken from these guys that you're doing a bright star, that's maybe a little bit different from a training and development of your investors and your wider team in the firm?
23:44
So if you think of where I started the conversation, it was an appreciation for the apprentice model. I just spoke about organizations that are excellent at training. And obviously a lot of the training is on the job training, but it's purposeful. I think a bright star were fairly purposeful in our training. How do we match up team members to get a broad-based experience? How do we match people up to put them environments to challenge them? We have a chief marketing officer who spent 20 years.
24:12
in front of a camera as a news anchor. We hired him prior to the pandemic, but actually one of most important skills in training is not just what we do on investing on a day-to-day basis, but how we're able to communicate and articulate it to a number of our stakeholders. When we're in the room with a business, how are we able to articulate our value proposition? The same with our investors. And so behind the scenes,
24:39
a lot of us do a lot of training and how to speak because it turned out that actually being able to go on camera on zoom on teams, whatever venue actually was critically important. Um, and as important as the content is the way we communicate it also is critically important. And I can say, going back to my training 30 years ago as an analyst, we really didn't get any training on how to do public speaking. We didn't get any training in front of a camera like this. And now that's actually one of the critical.
25:09
skills. That training is also pervasive in how we think about preparing. We talk a lot about Bright Star about being prepared, being prepared when we meet someone, being prepared for the number of outcomes that we might be looking at. And so part of training also is a deliberate approach to be prepared for every room that we go into as best that we can. What's one book, framework or resource that's had the biggest influence on your career?
25:39
Yeah, I'll go for it. I'll go for two books just because I'm going to take the liberty to do that. I'm to go, you know, off ask on that one. One goes back to college and it was The History of Crashes by Galbraith. And I love it because it's a four to five hundred year old story chronicling. When things don't go well, what was the behavioral pattern that led up to it?
26:05
This goes from the Dutch tulip craze to the Tantine scheme in France to the depression in 29. And you see basically the same patterns and I love it because the ability to identify patterns and pattern recognition is so critical for our business that looking for those breadcrumbs or that sign of what's about to come and it's usually inevitable in the same regard. We don't live every day assuming the crash will happen tomorrow.
26:35
but we want to know what we would do or what are the signs that come in advance to position ourselves from a risk environment. The second one I'm going to give you is by Lewis. It's Liar's Poker. know, for me, it was like one of those foundational books along with the movie Wall Street. The movie Wall Street, I liked the first 80%, the last 20, you know, it was a little bit of a downward spiral, but the first 80 were pretty inspirational. But I think of Liar's Poker and just...
27:03
I never operated in that environment. I didn't grow up in that environment. And I feel like the author really engaged in really building this world of problem solving, just dealing with some of the smartest people in the world and in the Wall Street world. And how are they thinking? How do they build markets that didn't even exist? So I love reading about pioneers and entrepreneurs and following how the story goes.
27:30
And how does anybody get in touch with you post this podcast? I can definitely work with you folks to make it make a, you know, some type of email or communication available. always love to hear from people. I'd say we're always looking for smart people at Bright Start. We're looking for great companies to invest in. And we're always looking to hear from people, you know, from a, from a, from an investment perspective, I think we've acquired more than 50 companies in the last two years.
27:59
So we're fairly active. So if you look at our portfolio and where we're invested, we especially want to hear from that audience. I that's fairly, think that's a definition of very active is 50. Well, thank you very much for coming onto the podcast, Andrew, and I appreciate your time. Thanks so much, Alex. I really enjoyed it. And as always, thank you very much to all of our listeners. Till the next time, keep smashing it.